Evidence / EX-39 / 2026-01-03
Registered letter to then-CEO Enrique Lores, delivered to HP headquarters
Sent after HP had closed the case and refused the exchange. Delivered to HP’s Palo Alto headquarters on January 20, 2026, per USPS Tracking. No response.
From: Rick Barnett (customer)
To: Enrique Lores, then-President and Chief Executive Officer, HP Inc., 1501 Page Mill Road, Palo Alto, CA 94304
Dated: January 3, 2026
Sent by: USPS registered mail, tracking 9589071052703486638634
Delivered: January 20, 2026, 12:35 PM, front desk, reception area or mail room, Palo Alto, CA 94304 (USPS Tracking)
To: Enrique Lores, then-President and Chief Executive Officer, HP Inc., 1501 Page Mill Road, Palo Alto, CA 94304
Dated: January 3, 2026
Sent by: USPS registered mail, tracking 9589071052703486638634
Delivered: January 20, 2026, 12:35 PM, front desk, reception area or mail room, Palo Alto, CA 94304 (USPS Tracking)
January 3, 2026 Enrique Lores President and Chief Executive Officer HP Inc. 1501 Page Mill Road Palo Alto, CA 94304 USA Re: Case #5144181121 | Exchange Order #H302745221 | HP ZBook G11 Mobile Workstation | SKU A20H5UA#ABA Dear Mr. Lores, I am writing to you in your capacity as HP’s President and CEO with responsibility for executive accountability and customer policy compliance. I have been attempting to get HP to comply with its published exchange policy for nearly 200 days. This letter concerns one issue: HP canceled an approved exchange for a defective HP ZBook G11 Mobile Workstation (SKU A20H5UA#ABA) using a reason that directly contradicts HP’s published exchange policy. Facts: • HP shipped me an HP ZBook G11 Mobile Workstation (SKU A20H5UA#ABA) that failed within 30 days. • HP approved an exchange and issued Exchange Order #H302745221. • I returned the defective unit and HP confirmed receipt. • On July 18, 2025, HP canceled the approved exchange and processed a refund. • Executive Escalations stated the exchange was canceled because the item was “out of stock.” HP’s Published Policy: HP’s exchange policy for defective items states: “If you have received a damaged or defective item, we will send you a replacement of the same or similar product.” The Conflict: “Out of stock” is not a policy basis to cancel an approved exchange. HP’s published standard is “same or similar,” not “identical or nothing.” If the exact SKU is unavailable, the policy requires HP to provide a similar replacement, not cancel the exchange and substitute a refund. Question: What written HP policy authorizes canceling an approved exchange based on “out of stock” when HP’s published standard explicitly provides for “similar” replacements? Leadership Concern: HP’s Chief Commercial Officer, David McQuarrie, wrote to me that he asked his escalations manager to contact me and would ensure this was “getting closed satisfactorily.” No follow-up occurred from either Mr. McQuarrie or his team. Request: Please confirm in writing that HP will complete the approved exchange under the published “same or similar” standard. Because HP has delayed this matter nearly 200 days, I will not be home to receive an exchange shipment until June 2026. At that time, I expect a current model year replacement that meets the “same or similar” specification standard. Please provide your written response within 30 days. Sincerely, Rick Barnett ████ [address redacted] Email: [customer email] Phone: ████ [phone] Enclosures: • July 18, 2025 cancellation/refund email • HP exchange policy excerpt (“same or similar”) • Executive Escalations correspondence citing “out of stock” • David McQuarrie commitment to resolution