Honor/Your/Policy☰ Case index
HP Chief Commercial Officer

David McQuarrie

He wrote that he would follow it up personally. This is what happened next, in HP’s own messages.

HP approved an exchange for a defective ZBook workstation in writing, received the returned unit, then cancelled the replacement and issued a refund instead (HP Case #5144181121). In November 2025 the case reached David McQuarrie, HP’s Chief Commercial Officer.

Days since “I will follow it up personally”
332
The record

Personally

  1. Nov 20, 2025
    David McQuarrie, HP Chief Commercial Officer — “I will follow it up personally with the Exec escalations manager.”
    Show the original · EX-27
    EX-27 · originalOpen full exhibit ↗
    David McQuarrie, HP Chief Commercial Officer: “I will follow it up personally”
  2. Dec 5, 2025
    David McQuarrie, HP Chief Commercial Officer — “I would like to follow up and resolve this.”
    Show the original · EX-29
    EX-29 · originalOpen full exhibit ↗
    David McQuarrie, HP Chief Commercial Officer: “I would like to follow up and resolve this”
  3. Dec 8, 2025
    David McQuarrie, HP Chief Commercial Officer — “I will check in again tomorrow to ensure that this is getting closed satisfactorily.”
    Show the original · EX-30
    EX-30 · originalOpen full exhibit ↗
    David McQuarrie, HP Chief Commercial Officer: “closed satisfactorily”
  4. Dec 17, 2025
    Nine days later — The LinkedIn conversation with David McQuarrie now reads: “LinkedIn member unable to receive messages.”
    Show the original · EX-31
    EX-31 · originalOpen full exhibit ↗
    “LinkedIn member unable to receive messages”
  5. Feb 9, 2026
    The customer emails David McQuarrie directly. Five minutes later the reply comes from ECR Executive Escalations, not from Mr. McQuarrie: “No other action can or will be taken on your previous order, including replacement.”
    Record: EX-34
  6. Feb 9, 2026
    The customer asks HP to confirm whether David McQuarrie personally received his email. ECR Executive Escalations: “No additional information will be provided.”
    Record: EX-35
HP.com Returns & Exchanges — the policy, as published
“If you have received a damaged or defective item, we will send you a replacement for the same or similar product.”

Mr. McQuarrie, you said personally. Honor your policy.

#HonorYourPolicy

Has HP done this to you? Be heard.