HP Chief Commercial Officer
David McQuarrie
He wrote that he would follow it up personally. This is what happened next, in HP’s own messages.
HP approved an exchange for a defective ZBook workstation in writing, received the returned unit, then cancelled the replacement and issued a refund instead (HP Case #5144181121). In November 2025 the case reached David McQuarrie, HP’s Chief Commercial Officer.
Days since “I will follow it up personally”
332
The record
Personally
- Nov 20, 2025David McQuarrie, HP Chief Commercial Officer — “I will follow it up personally with the Exec escalations manager.”
Show the original · EX-27
EX-27 · originalOpen full exhibit ↗
- Dec 5, 2025David McQuarrie, HP Chief Commercial Officer — “I would like to follow up and resolve this.”
Show the original · EX-29
EX-29 · originalOpen full exhibit ↗
- Dec 8, 2025David McQuarrie, HP Chief Commercial Officer — “I will check in again tomorrow to ensure that this is getting closed satisfactorily.”
Show the original · EX-30
EX-30 · originalOpen full exhibit ↗
- Dec 17, 2025Nine days later — The LinkedIn conversation with David McQuarrie now reads: “LinkedIn member unable to receive messages.”
Show the original · EX-31
EX-31 · originalOpen full exhibit ↗
- Feb 9, 2026The customer emails David McQuarrie directly. Five minutes later the reply comes from ECR Executive Escalations, not from Mr. McQuarrie: “No other action can or will be taken on your previous order, including replacement.”Record: EX-34
- Feb 9, 2026The customer asks HP to confirm whether David McQuarrie personally received his email. ECR Executive Escalations: “No additional information will be provided.”Record: EX-35
HP.com Returns & Exchanges — the policy, as published
“If you have received a damaged or defective item, we will send you a replacement for the same or similar product.”