Honor/Your/Policy☰ Case index
Evidence / EX-40 / 2026-02-09

Email to HP’s General Counsel and Board Chair, answered by Executive Escalations three minutes later

Addressed only to Julie Jacobs (General Counsel) and Chip Bergh (Chair of the Board). The reply came from Executive Escalations, the team whose decision the email questioned. Sent the same afternoon as EX-34.
From: ECR Executive Escalations <[email protected]>
To: Rick Barnett [customer email]
Sent: February 9, 2026, 4:08 PM PST
Subject: RE: Subject: Governance Concern - Case #5144181121 | Executive Accountability
Hello Rick,

We have made our position clear on the matter of your complaint.

Your order was returned and refunded, and as such is closed.
HP and HP.com reserve the right to close/cancel any HP.com orders at any time for any reason.
No other action can or will be taken on your previous order, including replacement.

If you have any further comments, complaints, or questions, please provide them to our team directly.
If you wish to proceed with a new order, please let us know and we'd be happy to get this setup.

Regards,

ECR Executive Escalations
Global Executive Escalations
HP Inc.
USA


From: Rick Barnett <[customer email]>
Sent: Monday, February 9, 2026 5:05 PM
To: Jacobs, Julie <[HP email redacted]>; Chip Bergh <[HP email redacted]>
Subject: Subject: Governance Concern - Case #5144181121 | Executive Accountability

CAUTION: External Email
Subject: Governance Concern - Case #5144181121 | Executive Accountability
Julie Jacobs
Executive Vice President, General Counsel
HP Inc.
Ms. Jacobs,
I am writing regarding a governance concern related to Case #5144181121.
On December 8, 2025, David McQuarrie (Chief Commercial Officer) committed in writing to "check in again tomorrow to ensure that this is getting closed satisfactorily" regarding my warranty exchange case.
On February 9, 2026, I sent Mr. McQuarrie a letter via email requesting he honor that commitment. Within 5 minutes, HP's Executive Escalations team responded with a generic template. Mr. McQuarrie has not responded.
This is part of a documented pattern where every escalation - including to CEO Enrique Lores, the Board of Directors, Board Chair Chip Bergh, and now Mr. McQuarrie - results in responses from the Executive Escalations team rather than the executives to whom correspondence was directed.
The underlying issue is straightforward:

  *   June 11, 2025: HP approved warranty exchange (Order #H302745221)
  *   July 12, 2025: I returned defective ZBook G11, HP received it
  *   July 18, 2025: HP cancelled approved exchange, issued refund
  *   HP's policy: "same or similar product" replacement for defective items
  *   241 days later: No replacement provided
What HP's own team has confirmed:

  *   July 25, 2025 (Josh Gonzales, Executive Escalations): "Ideally, this unit should have been replaced when you reported the issues."
  *   February 2, 2026 (ECR team): "HP and HP.com reserve the right to close/cancel any HP.com orders at any time for any reason."
That February 2 position renders HP's published "same or similar" exchange policy meaningless.
Governance concerns:

  1.  Executive correspondence is answered by the team whose decisions are being questioned, rather than by the executives themselves
  2.  An officer-level commitment (McQuarrie, December 8) remains unfulfilled with no accountability
  3.  HP's published exchange policy is being contradicted by internal claims of unlimited cancellation authority
  4.  FTC Complaint #192824541 filed October 16, 2025 - no response from HP
What I'm requesting:

  1.  Confirm receipt of this governance concern
  2.  Either: (A) Reinstate the approved exchange with current equivalent ZBook, or (B) Provide written explanation of why HP's "same or similar" policy doesn't apply after HP received the defective unit
  3.  Clarification on whether Mr. McQuarrie's December 8 commitment represents HP's position or not
I have sent registered mail to Mr. McQuarrie (January 12, USPS 9589071052703486638641) with no response.
This should not require legal intervention. HP approved an exchange, received defective hardware, and should honor its published policy.
Rick Barnett
Case #5144181121
[customer email]
████ [phone]
Attachments:

  *   February 9 letter to McQuarrie
  *   ECR response (5 minutes later)
  *   December 8 McQuarrie commitment

The customer’s email shows 5:05 PM on his own clock (UTC-7), which is 4:05 PM PST. HP’s reply header reads 00:08 UTC, February 10, which is 4:08 PM PST: three minutes later.

#HonorYourPolicy

Has HP done this to you? Be heard.