Evidence / EX-38 / 2026-02-10
Letter emailed directly to Bruce Broussard, HP’s interim CEO. No response.
Sent the day after Executive Escalations answered an email addressed to David McQuarrie (EX-34, EX-35).
From: Rick Barnett (customer and HP shareholder)
To: Bruce Broussard, Interim Chief Executive Officer, HP Inc. [HP email redacted]
Sent: February 10, 2026, 10:11 PM PST
Subject: Re: Documented Policy Compliance Failure — Warranty Exchange Case #5144181121
To: Bruce Broussard, Interim Chief Executive Officer, HP Inc. [HP email redacted]
Sent: February 10, 2026, 10:11 PM PST
Subject: Re: Documented Policy Compliance Failure — Warranty Exchange Case #5144181121
February 10, 2026 CONFIDENTIAL Mr. Bruce Broussard Interim Chief Executive Officer HP Inc. 1501 Page Mill Road Palo Alto, CA 94304 Re: Documented Policy Compliance Failure — Warranty Exchange Case #5144181121 Dear Mr. Broussard, Congratulations on your appointment as Interim CEO. I am writing to you directly as both an HP shareholder and the affected customer in the matter referenced above, which involves a documented failure to comply with HP’s published warranty exchange policy. Summary of Facts In July 2025, HP approved a warranty exchange for a defective laptop under HP's published "same or similar" replacement policy. I returned the defective unit as instructed. HP received and processed the return. On July 25, 2025, HP's own Order Management Specialist ([Order Management specialist], Boise, Idaho) identified two comparable systems — both HP ZBook Power 16 inch G11 models with 3-year warranties and offered them to me at a discounted purchase price. HP did not fulfill the approved exchange with either of these units. Instead, HP canceled the exchange, issued a refund, and closed the matter. Seven months later, HP's Executive Customer Relations unit shifted to the position that HP may "close/cancel any HP.com orders at any time for any reason." HP's own records confirm that "same or similar" systems were available at the time of cancellation. HP identified them, contacted me about them, but chose to offer a discounted sale rather than fulfill the approved warranty exchange. HP has not provided any evidence that a policy-compliant "same or similar" evaluation was performed, nor any written justification for converting an approved exchange into a refund. I have specifically requested this information in writing. The ECR Gatekeeper Problem I have made multiple documented attempts to escalate this matter through HP’s published governance channels, including the CEO office, General Counsel, Board Secretary, and board-facing channels. Every communication, regardless of the intended recipient, has been intercepted and responded to exclusively by HP’s Executive Customer Relations (ECR) unit, which has declared the matter “closed” with “no further elevation, transfer, or review.” ECR has put the following in writing: “Your order was returned and refunded, and as such is closed.” “HP and HP.com reserve the right to close/cancel any HP.com orders at any time for any reason.” “No other action can or will be taken on your previous order, including replacement.” “There will be no further elevation, transfer, or review of this matter.” This means a subordinate customer service unit is functioning as the sole and final authority on policy compliance disputes, blocking shareholder and customer access to HP’s executive leadership and governance structure. This is a governance concern, not a customer service complaint. What I Am Requesting A) Reinstate the approved exchange and fulfill it with a current model-year equivalent system consistent with HP’s “same or similar” policy, with a confirmed ship date and accountable decision owner; or B) Provide the specific written policy or internal control that permits HP to cancel an approved warranty exchange after receiving the defective return, and identify the accountable owner of that policy and this decision. I have submitted detailed questions to ECR on this date requiring written responses. I am copying you because ECR has stated no further escalation is possible, and I want to ensure you are personally aware of this matter as you assume leadership of HP. I am preserving all correspondence related to this matter for potential regulatory filing, legal action, and shareholder advocacy purposes. Respectfully, Rick Barnett HP Shareholder Case #5144181121
No response. Mr. Broussard had also been messaged directly on November 30, 2025 (EX-28). He becomes Chair of HP’s Board on January 4, 2027.